I've been watching this "Joe the Plumber" thing with a good deal of amusement. Because, on one level, it's amazingly stupid, and the idea that it could have a major effect on the US Presidential election is, frankly, nuts.
But.
OTOH, it's emblematic of why the US is the greatest country in the world.
How it began:
A relatively ordinary American
decided to question the front runner to being the most powerful person in the world, and
got the following responseIt's not that I want to punish your success. I just want to make sure that everybody that is behind you, that they have a chance for success too.
...
I think when you spread the wealth around, it’s good for everybody.
I believe the correct term here is "
epic fail".
We Americans are, by far, the most charitable people in the world. We give more to the less fortunate, of both our time and our money, than anyone else in the world. (And when the shit hits the fan elsewhere, we're the first there, with the best help.)
But, we are a people who look upward. Our ideal is the "self made man." Our iconic story is "rags to riches." We want our kids to do better than us. And our hero is Michael Phelps, not the guy who came in second place.
Now, as a matter of economics, what Obama said was imbecilic. More money in the hands of a crack-head, or an alcoholic, isn't "better for everybody" than more money in the hands of someone who's going to invest in wisely in a money making businesses.
As a matter of politics, it's worse. Because the last thing in the world a redistributionist wants for you to think about is "all the people behind you." "In front of me" are the people with tax attorneys and political connections who will take care of themselves. "Behind me" are the people Obama is going to "help."
I'm screwed.We don't think of ourselves as the "losers" who need the government's help. We're Americans, we're winners. Certainly those people in the mushy middle, the 15 - 20% who don't pay attention until about 2 - 3 weeks before the election, and who decide the election, don't think of themselves as "the people behind."
So that was a losing encounter for Obama. Oh, well. Happens all the time.
However, this one may cost him the election.
1: The people who decide President elections are just now actually starting to pay attention to what's going on. A month ago this would have disappeared. Now, it probably won't.
2: Joe isn't going away.
In most of the world, an ordinary person who was in Joe's position would duck his head and try to hide, in fear of what would happen to him after the politician won. We don't fear that in the US.
In most of the rest of the world, "Joe the Plumber" would be a nothing. He hasn't gone to the "right schools", he doesn't know the "right people", he's not a member of "the elite." He just wouldn't matter.
Here
he's interviewed by Katie Couric about the Presidential Debate on national TV. And does well.
Joe's from Ohio. If Obama loses Ohio and Pennsylvania (next door neighbor, demographically similar, and the kind of place where Joe should wear well), you can pretty much kiss the election goodbye. Smearing him is another loser. Joe isn't running for office. What matters about him is his ideas. Every smear you throw at him is an admission that his ideas are unassailable.